Encoder Comparison NVENC x264 Quicksync QSV VP9 and AV1

AV1

History

AV1 was finalised in 2018 and is the sequel to VP9. Like it’s predecessor, it is also royalty free. AV1 saves about as much data for the same quality from H.265, as what H.265 did from H.264. It truly is the next generation video standard in terms of bandwidth saving and improved quality. FFMPEG includes libaom-av1 as the free software encoder for AV1. There are some others out there, but they are still in the early stages of development. AV1’s biggest drawback is its extraordinary level of complexity. Currently, just playing a 1440p 60fps video hammers most consumer CPUs bought before 2019. I include it in this analysis just to compare quality per bandwidth to the current popular encoders. At the time of writing this, it is not feasible to live-stream using AV1 in OBS.

This analysis uses version libaom-av1 1.0.0-900-g7715ae1c7. There are issues with bitrate conformance that I had to try and resolve, but the basic command is as follows:

ffmpeg -y -i original.mkv -c:v libaom-av1 -strict experimental -b:v 6M -pass 1 -an -cpu-used 3 -tile-columns 4 -tile-rows 4 -row-mt 1 -threads 4 -f matroska NUL && ^
ffmpeg -y -i original.mkv -c:v libaom-av1 -strict experimental -b:v 6M -pass 2 -an -cpu-used 3 -tile-columns 4 -tile-rows 4 -row-mt 1 -threads 4 -f matroska AV1_6_CPU3_t4x4_th4.mkv
AV1 VMAF Scores on 2560x1440 60 fps
AV1 VMAF Scores on 2560×1440 60 fps

Results

The results speak for themselves. Here’s some things to take note of:

  • AV1 beats all other tested codecs, at all tested bitrates.
  • AV1 at 3Mbps and lower had bitrate conformity issues. The results are there as a curiosity and should be taken with a grain of salt. The final file sizes suggest that libaom-av1 resists staying under the limit and ends up cheating.
  • AV1 at 6Mbps beats all H.264 AVC and H.265 HEVC at 8Mbps, even Turing and x265 Slow. In fact, it’s nearly as good as VP9 at 8Mbps.

AV1 achieved all that marvellous increased quality and bandwidth savings with speed 3 and 4. The possible range is 0 to 8, with 8 being the fastest. It’s possible that speed 0 through 2 will be even better. But I didn’t have the patience to test more presets because of how long it takes. Comment below if you’d like to see this in the future.

Additional

AV1 doesn’t just improve quality or reduce bitrates. It provides additional features that simply aren’t in other codecs. One example is S-Frames. In current codecs, viewers may need to switch quality mid-stream if they experience connection issues. This currently requires a key frame. The more key frames in a video the more seamless this switch happens. However, key frames use more bandwidth, the more frequent they are, the more bandwidth the video uses overall. AV1 implements S-Frames (switch frames) to change this. S-Frames are less data intensive than key frames, but still enable switching. There’s a good description on it by Tarek Amara from Twitch here:

Google has started testing AV1 on YouTube to study browser compatibility. If you have Chrome for desktop release 70 or later, check out this video by Dua Lipa. Should Google think you can play it, you’ll get the AV1 version, if not you will get the VP9 version. If you can’t play VP9, you’ll get the H.264 AVC version.

Conclusions for AV1

Although the bitstream is finalised, the encoders are not. It’s still very new and bound to get faster. There is a long way to go though. Encoding at cpu-used 3 gave a speed of 0.0016x the source test video. That is 625 times slower than the 60 fps needed to stream live. The encoder would have to become 25x more efficient, and CPUs 25x faster, to reach real-time on this test. It’s a long way off regular consumer Twitch streaming capability, but it looks very promising.

UNREAL AUSSIES ARE ALL OVER THE WEB

HELP SUPPORT
UNREAL AUSSIES

Unreal Aussies run many events over the year to help connect and build the Australian gaming community. If you are interested in helping out in any current or future planned events or wishing to offer some more ideas for us to explore - let us know!

About Us

Unreal Aussies is for passionate gamers from all walks of life. Games come and go, but the people still remain. From meetups to tournaments, hardcore teams to charity streams, Unreal Aussies core mission is to make gaming more fun as part of a community than it can ever be alone.